OPEN LETTER to Deputy Prime Minister and Cabinet Committee on federal response to COVID-19

In recent weeks cities across the country have seen an increase in hate crimes and racism related to COVID-19, particularly towards those of Asian-descent. In a Vancouver convenience store last month, a man hurled racist remarks related to COVID-19 at a 92- year-old man of Asian descent, before shoving him to the ground. Another assault was reported to the police where a visible minority woman was punched, grabbed by her hair, her face was slammed into the seats of skytrain and pushed out of the train. Similar disturbing incidents took place in Toronto where an Asian woman was hit by an umbrella, told to go back to where she came from and spat at. Most recently, a good samaritan intervened when an individual began to harassed two Asian women wearing protective masks on a bus by telling them to: "Go back to your own country; that's where it all started." The bystander was kicked, punched and wrestled to the ground by the suspect. Her hair was pulled so hard that a clump of hair was ripped from her scalp. Now, Dakota, an indigenous woman out walking her dog was punched in the face repeatedly and told to "go back to Asia".
Aside from such violent individual attacks, the Greater Vancouver Chinese Cultural Centre also saw hate messages written on their windows. The Millennium Gate in Vancouver's historic Chinatown was defaced with racist comments . These are just a few examples of the disturbing trends in the midst of COVID-19.

May 20, 2020

Hon. Chrystia Freeland, Chair
Cabinet Committee on the federal response to the coronavirus disease (COVID-19)

Hon. Steven Guilbeault Minister of Canadian Heritage

Dear Minister Freeland and Guilbeault,

Throughout the course of the COVID-19 pandemic everyone across Canada has been affected in one way or another - whether they have lost their job, closed down their business, witnessed a loved one fall ill, or lost someone they cherish. There is no ques0on that this is a difficult 0me. As this pandemic progresses, it is alarming to witness an increase in frequency acts of hate and racism.

In recent weeks cities across the country have seen an increase in hate crimes and racism related to COVID-19, particularly towards those of Asian-descent. In a Vancouver convenience store last month, a man hurled racist remarks related to COVID-19 at a 92- year-old man of Asian descent, before shoving him to the ground. Another assault was reported to the police where a visible minority woman was punched, grabbed by her hair, her face was slammed into the seats of skytrain and pushed out of the train. Similar disturbing incidents took place in Toronto where an Asian woman was hit by an umbrella, told to go back to where she came from and spat at. Most recently, a good samaritan intervened when an individual began to harassed two Asian women wearing protective masks on a bus by telling them to: "Go back to your own country; that's where it all started." The bystander was kicked, punched and wrestled to the ground by the suspect. Her hair was pulled so hard that a clump of hair was ripped from her scalp. Now, Dakota, an indigenous woman out walking her dog was punched in the face repeatedly and told to "go back to Asia".

Aside from such violent individual attacks, the Greater Vancouver Chinese Cultural Centre also saw hate messages written on their windows. The Millennium Gate in Vancouver's historic Chinatown was defaced with racist comments . These are just a few examples of the disturbing trends in the midst of COVID-19.

Vancouver police has confirmed that they have seen an increase in reports of hate crimes targeting members of the Asian community. This is yet another painful reminder that Canada is not immune to racism and discrimination.

Given the above, I would like to reinforce the need for the government to take the necessary measures to stand against all forms of systemic discrimination and racism. We must quell the increasing public climate of hate and fear and offer protection and support to all Canadians from coast to coast against these despicable acts.

Drawing from the lessons learned through the Standing Committee on Heritage’s study on Motion-103, I would like to renew my calls for action presented in my supplementary report. The full report and its 28 recommenda0ons could be found here - https:// www.ourcommons.ca/DocumentViewer/en/42-1/CHPC/report-10/page-210. In particular, I would like to highlight a few of the recommendations for action.

First, with the rise in hate crimes, I am calling on the Government of Canada to show leadership by hos0ng a federal-provincial-territorial meeting to discuss the rise in hate crimes in Canada and to coordinate our collective efforts and iden0fy best practices to countering this trend.

Second, it is unacceptable that not all police departments in Canada have a dedicated hate crime unit. To effectively hold perpetuator of hate to account, it is essential
that the Government of Canada collaborate with municipalities, provinces, and territories to create and properly fund dedicated police hate crime units in every police department in Canada.

Third, in order to be9er protect minority groups from hate incidents, we must take hate motivation into account more effectively and consistently. The Government of Canada should establish national standards for identifying and recording all hate incidents and their dispensation in the justice system.

Finally, given that many of the hate crimes go unreported for a variety of reasons, it is essential that we make every effort to facilitate the reporting of racist and hate activities. I am therefore urging the Government of Canada to work in collaboration with non- profits to facilitate the reporting of hate crimes. This work is important to ensure
the perpetuators are held accountable, it is also critical that there is accurate collection of this data.

I urge that you take immediate action to implement these recommendations. I remain ready and willing to work collaboratively with you to fight against racism and discrimination in all its forms. Thank you for your attention on this important matter and I look forward to your response.

Sincerely,

Jenny Kwan
Member of Parliament Vancouver East

Cc:
The Hon. Jean-Yves Duclos (Vice-Chair) The Hon. Navdeep Singh Bains
The Hon. William Sterling Blair
The Hon. Patricia Hajdu
The Hon. Mélanie Joly
The Hon. William Francis Morneau The Hon. Carla Qualtrough
The Hon. Kirsty Duncan
The Hon. Mary Ng

Latest posts

Media Release: NDP calls on PM Carney to demand Indian PM Modi's full cooperation with Canadian law enforcement into targeted killings and surveillance in Canada at G-7

FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE:
13.6.2025

NDP Calls on PM Carney to Demand Indian PM Modi’s Full Cooperation with Canadian Law Enforcement into Targeted Killings and Surveillance in Canada at G-7

OTTAWA – Today, NDP MP Jenny Kwan called on PM Mark Carney to challenge Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi at the G-7 directly over India’s refusal to cooperate with Canadian law enforcement investigations into multiple acts of foreign interference—including murder and surveillance.

In 2023, Canadian authorities publicly linked the assassination of Hardeep Singh Nijjar—a Sikh community leader in Surrey, B.C.—to agents of the Indian government. Since then, India has refused to assist the RCMP in its criminal investigation. Now, alarming new revelations from Global News indicate that former NDP Leader Jagmeet Singh was placed under RCMP protection after being targeted for surveillance by a suspected Indian government agent with ties to the Lawrence Bishnoi criminal network.

“These are Canadian lives under threat and targeted for violence. The Prime Minister must use the G7 summit to demand full cooperation from Modi on Canadian soil, in front of the world,” said Jenny Kwan.

The agent who tracked Singh reportedly had access to personal information about his family, his travel, and his daily routine. Singh’s case is part of a growing pattern of Indian interference targeting members of the Sikh diaspora and critics of the Modi government—activities that violate Canada’s sovereignty and national security.

“We cannot allow political leaders to be surveilled, community leaders to be murdered, and foreign agents to operate with impunity in this country,” said Kwan. “If Prime Minister Carney won’t challenge Modi now—at this global forum, with the world watching—then when will he?”

The NDP is calling on the Prime Minister to:

Demand full cooperation from the Indian Prime Minister Modi in the Nijjar investigation and other open cases;
Demand accountability for the surveillance of Jagmeet Singh and other Canadians;
Commit to reporting to Parliament India’s role in extrajudicial killings and other criminal acts on Canadian soil;
Take concrete steps to protect Canadian communities from transnational repression,including providing security to civilians; and
Take immediate action to put in place the Foreign Agent Registry.

Kwan also asked the following question in Parliament on the eve of the G7 Summit, with reply from the Foreign Affairs Parliamentary Secretary:

Jenny Kwan (Vancouver East, NDP): Mr. Speaker, the Prime Minister and Pierre Poilievre both want to roll out the red carpet for Prime Minister Modi to attend the G7 summit in Canada, knowing Modi refused to co-operate with the RCMP in the investigation of the murder of Nijjar and other homicides on Canadian soil.

The Prime Minister will not say if he knew Jagmeet Singh's life was in danger and was under surveillance by gang members suspected of working for the Indian government. Poilievre's excuse is that he refused to get the security clearance, but the Prime Minister has none.

Will the Prime Minister rescind the invitation and demand India's full co-operation in the Nijjar murder and other cases?

Hon. Robert Oliphant (Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister of Foreign Affairs, Lib.): Mr. Speaker, the member has raised several issues at the same time. Let me just say the G7 is a huge opportunity for Canada to exercise leadership on the world stage. Our sovereignty, our security and prosperity are tied to global security.

At the same time, Canada is a country of the rule of law. We have cases before the RCMP.

We will continue to have those investigations. We will continue to ensure Canadians are safe at home and abroad.

Media Statement: Bill C-5 undermines the democratic process, the right of Indigenous People, the rights and safety of workers, and critical environmental protections

Bill C-5 undermines the democratic process, the rights of Indigenous Peoples, the rights and safety of workers, and critical environmental protections.

The NDP opposes this bill in its current form.

Through Bill C-5, Carney is using the threat of Trump's tariffs to provide Cabinet and Ministers with overreaching powers to eliminate environmental oversight, violate Constitutional obligations to Indigenous peoples, and lower labour standards for workers throughout Canada.

There is no doubt that the unjustified and illegal trade war initiated by Trump opens an opportunity to buy and build more of what we need at home and make sure workers and Indigenous people benefit.

Although Part 1 of C-5 deserves positive consideration, we have many grave concerns about part two of Bill C-5. That is why the NDP will oppose fast-tracking this legislation and will oppose this bill in its current form.

CBC News: Are there 'snooping provisions' in Carney's massive border bill?

Public Safety Minister Gary Anandasangaree, who has a background in asylum and human rights law, said he would never advance a bill that threatens civil liberties.

"It needed to be in line with the values of the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms," he said the day the bill was tabled. "I fundamentally believe that we can strike a balance that, while expanding powers in certain instances, does have the safeguards and the protections in place like protecting individual freedoms or rights."

The NDP's Kwan isn't convinced.

"I know the minister says this and believes it," she said. "But in reality, if you look at the bill, the minister is creating a situation where your personal info is being disclosed without your consent."