OPEN LETTER to Deputy Prime Minister, Minister of Finance, Minister of Employment and Minister of Immigration on support emergency support for migrant workers and temporary residents

The Covid 19 pandemic has impacted everyone across Canada. I am writing to you today with my concerns about the desperate need for support for migrant workers and temporary residents during this COVID-19 pandemic. While it is welcomed that the government has put in place the Canadian Emergency Response Benefit (CERB) as income support for eligible individuals including migrant workers; unfortunately, the reality for many in this country is that they s5ll cannot access it. In particular, I would like to flag to your attention the countless migrant workers and temporary residents across the country who are in dire need.
With the current CERB requirements, those applying must have a valid Social Insurance Number (SIN). This is a problem as many migrants do not have a valid SIN for a variety of reasons. It has come to my attention that the study permit for Alina Przybly, an international student from Toronto expired in January. Notwithstanding the fact that her employer closed the restaurant that she was working at because of the pandemic, due to processing delays at IRCC, she is unable to have her study permit extended. This has caused her SIN to expire. Without a valid SIN number, she is ineligible for CERB. Ms. Przybly is now in a dire situation through no fault of her own.

April 25, 2020

The Hon. Chrystia Freeland, Chair
Cabinet Commi<ee on the federal response to the coronavirus disease (COVID-19)

The Hon. Bill Morneau Minister of Finance

The Hon. Carla Qualtrough
Minister of Employment, Workforce Development and Disability Inclusion

The Hon. Marco Mendicino
Minister of Immigra5on, Refugee and Ci5zenship

Open Le'er re COVID-19 Migrant and Undocumented Workers

Dear Ministers,

The Covid 19 pandemic has impacted everyone across Canada. I am writing to you today with my concerns about the desperate need for support for migrant workers and temporary residents during this COVID-19 pandemic. While it is welcomed that the government has put in place the Canadian Emergency Response Benefit (CERB) as income support for eligible individuals including migrant workers; unfortunately, the reality for many in this country is that they s5ll cannot access it. In particular, I would like to flag to your attention the countless migrant workers and temporary residents across the country who are in dire need.

With the current CERB requirements, those applying must have a valid Social Insurance Number (SIN). This is a problem as many migrants do not have a valid SIN for a variety of reasons. It has come to my attention that the study permit for Alina Przybly, an international student from Toronto expired in January. Notwithstanding the fact that her employer closed the restaurant that she was working at because of the pandemic, due to processing delays at IRCC, she is unable to have her study permit extended. This has caused her SIN to expire. Without a valid SIN number, she is ineligible for CERB. Ms. Przybly is now in a dire situation through no fault of her own.

By not automatically extending the work or study visas as the NDP has advocated to ensure temporary foreign workers or foreign students impacted by this pandemic maintain their status, we now find ourselves in a situation where far too many temporary foreign workers or students are without status and unable to renew their SIN. Without a valid SIN, they are unable to apply for the Canadian Emergency Response Benefit.

In order to address this urgent situation, I am calling on the government to extend access to CERB to those whose SIN has expired. During the HUMA Commi<ee on April 24, 2020, I brought this issue to the attention of Minister Qualtrough. We are both in agreement that it is unacceptable that backlogs in

another government department is impeding individuals from getting the help they need at this critical 5me. As the matter also falls within the Ministry of Immigration and Finance, it would be imperative that officials work across departments to address the issue. Minister Qualtrough stated that she would further follow up with me on this. Please be advised that I would be very pleased to work with officials to ensure that this is rectified.

Additionally, to ensure migrants workers are support at this difficult time, we must ensure that workers who are forced to leave their jobs or those who have not started their contracts yet are not deemed to have “quit voluntarily”. Certain job conditions may become increasingly risky and/or dangerous during the time of COVID-19, and many may feel it would be irresponsible to con5nue this work. It is clear that workers in these situa5ons are only unable to work because of COVID-19, and it does not make sense for them to be excluded from CERB. As such, I am also calling for the government to provide support to undocumented residents in Canada. Like everyone else, undocumented workers needs to be able to follow Canada's Medical Health Officer's direc5ve to self-isolate to help flatten the curve. They need economic support just like other low wage and precarious workers.

Since the Individual Tax Number (ITN) is a unique number that Canada Revenue Agency uses to identify workers from tax purposes if they are not eligible for a SIN, the government could allow Individual Tax Numbers to be used in place of SINs. The ITN is a taxation mechanism that already exists and as such could be easily extended to workers who do not have access to SINs. This would be an efficient and cost effective mechanism for addressing the urgent need for income supports. In addition, the expansion of the use of ITNs would allow more workers to contribute to Canada’s tax base going forward and have a positive impact on the long-term health of the tax system. To protect the privacy of the undocumented workers, informa5on collected for tax purposes or for issuance of emergency economic support must not be shared with other government departments.

We are facing an international public health crisis that does not discriminate and providing income support to everyone in need during this 5me is crucial. Migrant workers must have the right to participate in the public health strategies our government is implemen5ng, and human rights need to be respected regardless of status.

We hope you take these recommendations into serious consideration, as thousands of workers are depending on your help in these trying 5mes.

Sincerely,
Jenny Kwan
MP, Vancouver East

Latest posts

Toronto Star NEWS: Canada launches ad campaign warning newcomers claiming asylum is ‘not easy’

When reached for comment, NDP immigration critic Jenny Kwan said the new measures are an abrupt shift from past policy.

“This about face from Prime Minister Trudeau is a shameless and insidious attempt to use newcomers such as migrants, international students, and asylum seekers as political cover,” Kwan said in a statement emailed to the Star.

It’s a dangerous game on Trudeau’s part, said Kwan, in trying to “shift the blame for his failures” to asylum seekers — one she called “a recipe to further hype-up hate, resentment and discrimination toward racialized people.

“Instead of wasting $250,000 on advertising, they should be investing those resources in processing applications,” said Kwan.

immigration.ca NEWS: Marc Miller to propose reforms to Canada’s Immigration and Asylum System

Political opposition has also been vocal. NDP immigration critic Jenny Kwan accused the government of scapegoating migrants for systemic issues, such as the housing crisis. Kwan called for a reversal of recent immigration changes, questioning their fairness to temporary residents and international students.

In response, Miller maintained that becoming a Canadian citizen is not a right.

Global NEWS: Sen. Woo downplays evidence that China ‘targeted’ MPs Chong, Kwan

In a statement, Kwan’s lawyer, Sujit Choudhry, said Woo’s allegation that the MP’s testimony was “flimsy” is “false and misleading.”

“It was CSIS who informed MP Kwan in a classified briefing that she was a long-time target of (Chinese Communist Party) interference and will remain an ‘evergreen target.’ MP Kwan testified and brought to the commissioner’s attention that she believed she had been de-platformed by Chinese community organizations,” Choudhry wrote in a statement to Global News.

Choudhry noted that CSIS officials testified that Beijing works through proxy agents in Canada’s Chinese diaspora and that Kwan is concerned the Chinese government used those proxies to target her for her advocacy on human rights issues in China.

“Senator Woo has every right to turn a blind eye to foreign interference actors and activities. MP Kwan chooses to use her voice to speak up and speak out to protect and defend Canada’s democratic institutions and processes.”