Open Letter to the Prime Minister on Kneecap

November 28, 2025

Prime Minister Mark Carney
House of Commons
Ottawa, ON K1A 0A6

Dear Prime Minister Carney,

Open letter re: Kneecap

I am writing to request your immediate intervention regarding the unresolved and deeply concerning circumstances surrounding the denied entry of members of the Irish musical group Kneecap and the serious questions this incident raises about transparency, process integrity, and potential political interference within Canada’s immigration system.

On October 2nd, I wrote to the Honourable Lena Diab, Minister of Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship, seeking clarification on several urgent matters. Those questions remain unanswered after two months. I have yet to receive a response. This lack of follow-up is unacceptable given both the significant implications for public confidence in the integrity of our immigration system and the public attention the case has received. I have now sent a follow up letter today on November 28th.

In my correspondence to Minister Diab, I outlined several troubling facts. The legal matter involving the group’s lead singer in the United Kingdom had been dismissed and declared “null and void,” resulting in no conviction. Yet on September 19, 2025—before the court decision—Liberal MP and Parliamentary Secretary for Combatting Crime

Vince Gasparro posted a video on X stating: “On behalf of the Government of Canada I am announcing that on the advice of our officials, we have deemed the group Kneecap ineligible to enter our country. Our government will not tolerate the advocating of political violence, terrorism or Anti-Semitism and hate more broadly.”

The band has publicly indicated that they received no communication from IRCC confirming any such decision. Nonetheless, several Canadian concerts were cancelled as a direct result of Mr. Gasparro’s announcement. Compounding this, the media received no clarification from your government: neither Mr. Gasparro nor Minister Diab confirmed or explained the basis for the announcement. Through an Order Paper Question response, IRCC subsequently confirmed that admissibility decisions are made exclusively by designated officers—not by elected
officials—and CBSA has stated that it was not consulted or involved in the decision by Parliamentary Secretary Gasparro to go public.

These contradictions and the refusal from your government to be accountable for the actions of a member of your appointed parliamentary secretaries raise deeply troubling questions about whether any department officials authorized the Parliamentary Secretary’s statement and why an elected official declared an immigration outcome without confirmation from the responsible authorities.

The opaque and inconsistent communication experienced by the band compounds the concern: one member had his eTA cancelled for "omitting to disclose complete and accurate information on his application", while the other two were simply advised not to travel because their applications remained under review with no timeline on when a decision would be made, nor was additional information requested for the application to complete the processing. I should note that while the Order paper Question response indicated that "[t]he applicant was notified of the reasons for this decision"; however, his legal counsel advised that the letter he received did not specify what were the reasons.

My letter to Minister Diab requested clarification on several critical points, including:

Whether members of Kneecap were ever formally banned from entry;
Whether Minister Diab or her officials authorized Mr. Gasparro to speak on IRCC’s behalf—and if not, who did;
Which officials Mr. Gasparro referenced in asserting he acted on their advice, and whether they had authority to grant such authorization;
Whether the members of Kneecap are currently permitted to enter Canada;
What IRCC’s decision-making process and criteria were used in this case, including any available appeal mechanisms.

To date, none of these questions have received a response.

Canadians deserve an immigration system that is transparent, fair, and protected from political interference. The serious inconsistencies between departmental statements and the public assertions made by an elected official demand urgent attention. Without clarity, the appearance of arbitrary or politicized decision-making will continue to undermine public trust.

I have since written a further letter to Minister Diab asking follow-up questions in light of the information provided in response to my Order Paper Questions. I therefore urge you to:

Direct the Minister of Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship to immediately respond in full to my October 2nd and November 28th follow up letter;
Clarify who within the Government of Canada advised or authorized MP Gasparro’s public announcement;
Confirm what steps your government will take to ensure that immigration decisions including those announced by any members of your parliamentary secretaries, are communicated lawfully, responsibly, and exclusively through the appropriate channels; and
Provide a definitive statement on the admissibility status of Kneecap’s members.

In this time of heightened misinformation and eroding public trust, it is essential that your government demonstrate a commitment to procedural integrity and non-partisanship in immigration decision-making.

I look forward to your prompt response.

Sincerely,
Jenny Kwan
Member of Parliament for Vancouver East
NDP Critic for Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship

Latest posts

iPOLITICS: Carney’s minority Liberals, opposition parties locked in existential impasse as sitting winds down

If the two-time former central bank governor had hopes that would be the beginning of a trend, however, the past three months would have made short work of any such unbridled — or even bridled — optimism.

Leaving aside the supply bills required to authorize pre-approved spending, since the House of Commons reopened for business on Sept. 16, the only government-initiated legislation to make it through a third reading vote was its bid to rejig the rules for recognizing the citizenship of the children of Canadians born abroad, which was introduced in response to a 2023 Ontario court ruling that found the current law to be unconstitutional with a court-imposed deadline of Nov. 21 to be in place before the offending sections would be automatically declared null and void.

Even that, it’s worth noting, wouldn’t have been possible without the support of the New Democrats — particularly B.C. MP Jenny Kwan, who, despite her party’s lack of official status, was nevertheless able to work with the government to reverse a series of changes made at committee by the Conservatives and the Bloc Québécois, which cleared the way for the bill to proceed to a third reading vote — and, ultimately, through the Senate. It was signed into law on Nov. 20, just one day before the existing law was set to expire, although by that point, the court had extended the deadline to Jan. 20, 2026, to allow for an orderly transition.

Click image or link to read the article - https://www.ipolitics.ca/2025/12/10/carneys-minority-liberals-opposition-parties-locked-in-existential-impasse-as-sitting-winds-down/

CPAC: NDP MPs Discuss Liberals’ Border Bill

NDP MPs Jenny Kwan and Leah Gazan hold a news conference on Parliament Hill to discuss Bill C-12, the Liberal government’s border security bill. They are joined by representatives from women’s organizations and advocates for immigrant and refugee rights. (December 9, 2025) (no interpretation)

Click image or link to watch the press conference video - https://www.cpac.ca/headline-politics/episode/ndp-mps-discuss-liberals-border-bill?id=4387467a-f6bc-4914-8f9a-57162568dfc6

Media Release: NDP MPs Join Women’s Organizations and Migrant Rights Advocates Condemning Bill C-12

NDP MPs Join Women’s Organizations and Migrant Rights Advocates Condemning Bill C-12

OTTAWA—NDP MPs Leah Gazan (Winnipeg Centre) and Jenny Kwan (Vancouver East) are standing alongside women’s organizations and migrant rights advocates calling on all Members of Parliament to reject the Liberals’ border and immigration legislation, Bill C-12, expected to be voted on at third reading this week.

“With Bill C-12, we’re again seeing the Liberals abandon their commitments to gender equality, pushing through legislation straight out of Trump’s playbook,” said Gazan. “Bill C-12 would place greater restrictions on women asylum seekers fleeing gender based violence, and would force many to stay in abusive relationships or unsafe working conditions as their immigration or refugee status is made more precarious. It clearly undermines women’s safety, but the Liberals do not seem to care.”

Among those joined by Gazan and Kwan include representatives of Fédération des femmes du Québec, Amnesty International, Centre des travailleurs et travailleuses immigrants, Action Réfugiés Montréal, and the Canadian Council for Refugees. According to these organizations, Bill C-12 retains many of the human rights violating provisions from the Government’s border bill, Bill C-2, which disproportionately harm women and gender diverse populations.

As NDP critic for Public Safety, MP Kwan shared her disappointment that the Liberals, Conservatives and Bloc Quebecois voted down NDP amendments to minimize harms on newcomers and asylum claimants. Civil society organizations have said loud and clear that Bill C-12 should be withdrawn. Despite that, the Liberals worked hand in glove with the Conservatives and Bloc to push it through the legislative process.

"Canada should not be violating migrants’ rights, especially those of women and children,” Kwan said. “I am dismayed that the Liberals have joined hands with both the Conservatives and Bloc to reject all of the NDP amendments, including amendments to exempt unaccompanied children, survivors of gender based violence and 2SLGBTQI+ members from being arbitrarily sent back to war zones, places ravaged by environmental disaster or where they face persecution due to their sexual orientation or gender identity."

“This bill is a total affront to dignity, fairness, due process and gender equality. The NDP will continue to fight for the rights of newcomers, migrants and refugees," said Kwan.